Or: Why I don't write book reviews.
I hate philosophy. People complain about moral decay and youths-these-days and the good times bygone, and they have been since the first time anyone reached adulthood and realized what shits people are.
Our youth now love luxury. They have bad manners,
contempt for authority; they show disrespect for their elders and love
chatter in place of exercise; they no longer rise when elders enter the
room; they contradict their parents, chatter before company; gobble up
their food and tyrannize their teachers.
-Socrates
I
tried listening to the Sunday Philosophy Club while waiting for my
shipment of Terry Pratchett books to come in, because without a book I start thinking in the car and
then getting mad about things - like how wasserface in the Fifth Element got all the way to W for War in her wikipedia thing before realizing people kill each other,
despite A for Apocalypse, B for Bioterrorism, G for Genocide, etc.
Maybe she was having a bathroom break or digging in the fridge while
those bits scrolled past. If I'm not getting mad about old movie scenes, I'm picking up memories and polishing them into buffed nuggets of remorse, anger, embarrassment, yearning, or evil intent. So it's best I just listen to audio books. I grabbed this particular one because I enjoyed the #1 Ladies' Detective Agency, but - well, The Sunday Philosophy Club is full of... philosophy. Before disc 1 was over, I was yelling at the stereo as I merged into traffic.
Does anyone ever smile intentionally?
YES. Yes, fucking YES - all the time, for everything. It's good manners. Who even asks that?
To love someone is to understand them completely, and forgive them.
NO. It's to think you understand them. Sometimes. Or maybe you love them against all practicality, for no good reason that you can tell, and maybe you kind of hate them, too. Forgiveness is an entirely different thing than love, they do not go hand in hand. It's much easier to forgive someone you don't give a shit about.
If one is committed to telling the truth, would they answer truthfully if a murderer arrived at the door, asking if their victim is in?
I get that the idea here is that a white lie could spare a life, but come on. If you were that committed to the truth, you could still get around this moral quandary. "Yes, and I will kill you with my own two hands, and maybe this vase right here, if you try to get in." "I am closing the door now" might also work. But I reject the idea that truth is an immutable force in the world. We are tiny little creatures faffing around and making noises, and truth is a figment of our imagination. There are natural events, and there is communication, and there is survival, and where they intersect we get very moralistic and long-winded. Also, there is redirection, if white lies are undesirable. "Was that good for you?" "Oh, let me tell you about the bits that were good!" "How do I look in this hat?" "You are too good-looking for that hat, give me that hat, bad hat." White lies vs Truth is a tired old argument. The main thing to live by when communicating with others is Don't Be an Asshole.
I turned the book back in at this point. I don't even care who threw McHandsomepants off the opera balcony. And the main character insulted Wagner. Life is too short for books that don't blow your kilt up, and that's my philosophy.